Today, with all kinds of investment options floating around, people are indeed spoiled for choice. Among those is the real estate option, and no doubt it is different from mutual funds, when it comes to returns, liquidity, risks, and tax benefits.
Now, if you are all confused and confused between an investment in land or a mutual fund, then we can really help you find the better of the two because of what is being elaborated further on.
Real estate overview
Real estate involves an investment in property such as residential or commercial, or even land. Real estate, over time, tends to appreciate, thus offering capital appreciation and also rental income.
However, real estate investments require substantial upfront capital and involve risks, such as market declines, property maintenance, and legal complexities. For those looking for alternatives with lower capital requirements, Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs) and Infrastructure Investment Trusts (InvITs) offer attractive options.
- REITs: These trusts pool money from investors to own and manage income-generating real estate properties like office spaces, malls, and hotels. They provide regular returns through dividends, as a significant portion of income is distributed to investors.
- InvITs: InvITs are similar but focus on infrastructure projects such as roads, power plants, and telecom towers. These investments offer exposure to the infrastructure sector with income distributed to investors.
To know more: Your guide to real estate investment trusts
Advantages of real estate investment
- Consistent passive income: Real estate can be a good source of passive income, which is ideal for those who want financial security or early retirement.
- Tangible asset: You can see and physically inspect real estate before buying it, so you can get tailored specifications to match your needs.
- Appreciation over time: Real estate appreciates with time and thus may result in capital gains.
- Diversification: Real estate is not correlated with equities and fixed income investments, thereby providing a good diversifier to the investment portfolio. Whenever equities fall, real estate generally stays stable or increases.
Disadvantages of real estate investment
- Illiquidity: There is no liquidity in selling real estate because it takes such a long time to get the right buyers or tenants for the property.
- High maintenance costs: Upkeep management and maintenance fee payment are added costs borne by the property owner in terms of total cost ownership.
- Market vulnerability: Property values may drop due to poor market conditions. This may lead to some losses.
- Time-consuming management: Finding tenable tenants and managing the property can be time-consuming and stressful.
Mutual funds: An overview
Mutual funds have remained a well-favoured investment option available for building wealth through portfolios professionally managed and diversified, thus being a pool for funds provided by multiple investors who direct the same amount towards investing in equities, bonds, and money-market instruments.
The industry’s growth momentum was seen in September 2024; total assets under management (AUM) stood at ₹67.09 lakh crore compared with ₹66.70 lakh crore in August-an expansion of ₹0.39 lakh crore or 0.58% month-on-month.
This performance showcases how market dynamics can directly impact returns, making mutual funds not only accessible across varying financial goals and risk profiles but also responsive to economic conditions and market trends.
Also read: SIP investment: Your path to wealth building
Advantages of mutual funds
- Liquidity: Units can be redeemed fast and sold into cash.
- Diversification: It invests money in different instruments that minimise the risk in a portfolio.
- Professional Management: Handled by professionally qualified fund managers.
- Low Investment Requirement: SIPs are launched with minimum amounts.
Disadvantages of mutual funds
- Market Risk: It depends on the prevailing market.
- Expense Ratio: It comprises the fund fees and will decrease the entire profit.
- Tax on Returns: Capital gains tax is deducted on profit.
Comparison: Mutual fund vs real estate
| Parameter | Real Estate | Mutual Funds |
| Capital Requirement | High | Low (starting at ₹500 via SIP) |
| Liquidity | Low (time-consuming to sell) | High (easily redeemable) |
| Returns | Dependent on location and demand | Linked to market performance |
| Risk | Market volatility, location risks | Market and fund-specific risks |
| Taxation | Stamp duty, capital gains tax | Capital gains tax (short/long term) |
| Management | Self-managed | Professionally managed |
| Inflation Hedge | Strong | Moderate |
You may also like: Gold vs Equities- Which is the right investment option?
Which is better investment land or mutual funds?
The choice between mutual funds vs real estate depends on individual financial goals, risk appetite, and investment preferences. Here are some points to consider:
- Returns and diversification: Mutual funds, especially equity funds, offer potential for higher returns along with diversification, but they carry market risks. Real estate, on the other hand, provides a tangible asset, though returns may accumulate more slowly.
- Risk tolerance: Those comfortable with market volatility may find mutual funds more suitable, while land offers a more stable but less liquid investment. However, property values can fluctuate based on location and market conditions.
- Investment horizon: Mutual funds are flexible, catering to both short-term and long-term goals. In contrast, land is typically a long-term investment, requiring time for value appreciation.
- Ease of investment: Buying land involves extensive paperwork, legal formalities, and significant upfront capital. Mutual funds, by comparison, offer easier entry points and can be accessed through online platforms, though they still require careful research and monitoring.
Both options come with their unique advantages and limitations, and the right choice depends on aligning them with personal financial strategies.
Conclusion
Advantages and disadvantages of both real estate and mutual funds. The real estate provides concrete ownership, rental income, but is not liquid and requires high capital. Mutual funds offer higher liquidity and diversification under professional management but returns depend on the market. A portfolio could be balanced through investment in mutual funds, providing liquidity, and an investment in real estate for long-term value.
FAQs
Is it wise to invest in land or mutual funds for long-term returns?
Real estate and mutual funds can offer viable options for long-term returns. Mutual funds, however, have higher liquidity in that investors can easily buy and sell shares as needed. Real estate is a tangible asset that often requires a longer time frame for appreciation. Although land investments are very lucrative over the long term, they do not offer as much flexibility as mutual funds do and require longer selling processes compared to the quick access to funds provided by mutual funds.
Which is safer, real estate or mutual funds?
It is considered a safe investment as real estate is a physical asset, thus seen by people and can be handled directly. This gives a sense of security in real estate to most investors as they can visualise it physically. Mutual funds offer the advantage of diversification when professionally managed. So, while real estate avails a sense of security just because of its physical look, mutual funds are put under proper management and diversification strategies.
Which is better investment land or mutual funds?
Mutual funds generate returns more over a period of time due to growth and performance in the markets. With a bullish market, one can enjoy fairly quick capital appreciation. With real estate, the opposite is often true: instead of making returns over shorter periods of time, an investor earns returns that could be steady over the long-term. While property value may appreciate over time, an investor earning rental income will also create a predictable cash flow stream.
What are the tax implications of investing in mutual funds versus real estate?
Stamps duty and long-term capital gain tax are also attracted with real estate investment. For mutual funds, capital gain tax is paid, but the rate depends on how long it has been held. Short-term capital gain tax is charged in case it has been held below a year, and for investments being held for over a year, long-term capital gains tax is levied. This would make the tax implications of mutual funds more variable based on how long you intend to hold your investment.
Can I invest small amounts regularly in real estate like the way I invest in mutual funds?
No, real estate investment generally demands a lot of front capital; it is generally not very accessible to many investors. Still, mutual funds provide one with the ease of being able to invest through Systematic Investment Plans wherein individuals can invest small amounts of money periodically. This brings mutual funds to a more extensive group of investors in light of their financial capacity. Thus, mutual funds serve the different tastes in investment and help create wealth over time without requiring big money initially.
