Shareholders agreement: What it is and why it matters

A shareholders agreement is a key contract that establishes the terms of the relationships between shareholders and the management of the firm. This agreement sets the governance structure of the business and explicitly defines out the rights, obligations, and responsibilities of shareholders. 

In this blog, we will delve deeper into what is a shareholders agreement, exploring its key components and the significant role it plays in corporate governance.

What is a shareholders agreement objective?

• Ownership details: The agreement outlines each shareholder’s ownership stake, detailing the number of shares owned and any restrictions on transferring these shares to third parties.
• Duration and termination: It specifies how long the agreement is valid, under what conditions it can be terminated, and how amendments can be made.
• Management structure: The document sets out the company’s management and decision-making framework, including shareholder’s voting rights and the appointment procedures for directors and officers.
• Roles and responsibilities: It defines the roles of officers, directors, and shareholders, specifying their duties and authorities, which helps streamline company operations.
• Dispute resolution: The agreement includes mechanisms for resolving disputes through arbitration or mediation, aiming to avoid costly and time-consuming litigation.
• Exit strategies: Features like buy-sell provisions articulate the process for a shareholder to sell or transfer shares, addressing scenarios such as death, disability, or retirement.
• Non-compete and confidentiality clauses: In order to safeguard the company’s interests, these clauses forbid shareholders from sharing proprietary information or engaging in rivalry with it.
• Dividend policy: If relevant, the agreement details how and when dividends are distributed to shareholders, clarifying financial returns on investment.
• Pre-emptive rights: By being the first to purchase newly issued shares from the company, these rights enable shareholders to keep their portion of the ownership.

This shareholders agreement format acts in tandem with the company’s Articles of Association, offering a more tailored approach to governance that complements the generic nature of company law. Effective and well-crafted, a shareholders agreement not only aligns shareholders with the company’s goals but also safeguards their investments and interests.

Benefits of shareholders agreement

• Privacy and confidentiality: A shareholders agreement is private, unlike corporate bylaws. It doesn’t need to be filed publicly, ensuring sensitive arrangements among shareholders remain confidential.
• Early structure and clarity: This agreement can be drafted before the company is officially formed, laying out the foundation for share issuance and capital contributions. This pre-emptive clarity helps avoid misunderstandings and aligns shareholder expectations from the beginning.
• Efficient dispute resolution: The agreement includes specific clauses for resolving deadlocks, which can expedite decision-making and prevent prolonged disputes from hindering company operations.
• Tailored to company needs: Unlike standard legal frameworks, a shareholders agreement is customised to the specific needs and goals of the business and its owners, providing a bespoke solution to corporate governance.

Limitations in the shareholders agreement

Here’s a brief overview of some potential constraints:

• Inconsistencies with governing documents: If a shareholder’s agreement conflicts with the company’s articles of association or other constitutional documents, it may compromise the agreement’s effectiveness. Ensuring alignment between all governance documents is critical.
• High notarization costs: In regions where notarization is required, fees may be based on the contract’s value. This can sometimes result in prohibitively high costs, which, if not addressed, may render the agreement unenforceable.
• Legal risks of collusion or monopoly: There’s a potential risk that shareholder’s agreements might be seen as facilitating anti-competitive practices. In certain cases, such agreements could be interpreted as evidence of collusion or monopoly, leading to legal challenges.

Shareholder interests with a shareholder’s agreement

Here are some key ways this agreement serves to safeguard shareholder interests:

• Protection for minority shareholders: The agreement can stipulate that major decisions require the approval of a certain percentage of minority shareholders, not just the majority. This prevents major shareholders from making unilateral decisions on critical issues like issuing new shares or bonds, which could dilute minority holdings.
• Security for majority shareholders: It ensures that the majority shareholders can operate effectively even if minority shareholders are not cooperative. Provisions can restrict minority shareholders from selling shares to competitors or other unwelcome parties, thus safeguarding the company’s interests and those of the majority.
• Legal structure and compliance: The agreement is legally binding and must be drafted with precision, typically by a legal professional who understands corporate law thoroughly. This ensures that the agreement not only meets legal standards but also addresses specific needs and objectives of the company and its shareholders effectively.
• Collective ownership and commitment: Ownership of the shareholder’s agreement is vested in all shareholders who sign it. This collective ownership underscores their mutual commitment to abide by the rules set out in the agreement, ensuring that all parties are aligned in their approach to managing the company.

Bottomline

A shareholders agreement format is a fundamental tool that enhances corporate governance, aligns interests, and protects investments, ensuring both company stability and shareholder security through clear, enforceable guidelines.

FAQs